Some of us just can’t help ourselves when we see a cat or dog on the street – we must pet it.

And while that’s really never a good idea (at least without asking permission, especially of dog owners), the pull is great for animal-lovers.

For years, a popular Twitter account called @thecatreviewer has retweeted photos and captions of the cats people have found while out and about along with a rating. The only rule is you can’t post a photo of your own cat (because, obviously, they get an infinity/10).

Of course, cats could care less about our ratings of them. And it’s a good thing too because anyone who gives a cat less than a 10/10 is a total monster.

Click ahead to see some of the fabulous felines people have encountered over the years (but also remember that cats live longer, healthier lives indoors!).